Serious misconduct is generally conduct so serious that an employer cannot have the employee in the workplace any longer. Typical examples of serious misconduct type behaviour include theft, fraud, violence, bullying, discrimination, gross negligence and serious breaches of health and safety procedures.
It is important that Employers can correctly classify the alleged conduct as serious misconduct because the process for addressing serious misconduct with an employee is different to normal performance management or misconduct management procedures. Typically, allegations of serious misconduct will need to be the subject of a comprehensive investigation by an Employer and sometimes it may be necessary to engage an external investigator.
We strongly recommend that Employers seek legal advice prior to terminating an employee’s employment for serious misconduct.
Common mistakes we see with termination for serious misconduct
- Employers consider misconduct to be serious misconduct when it does not meet the standard required
- Not conducting a full and thorough investigation into the allegations
- Not engaging an external investigator when appropriate (e.g. where there is conflict of interest or a difficulty being impartial)
- Not providing sufficient detail of the allegations to the employee so they can respond
- Not providing the employee with sufficient opportunity to respond to the allegations
- Not genuinely considering the employee’s response to the allegations
- Not allowing the employee to have a support person at a meeting involving dismissal when one is requested
Key risks of getting it wrong
Improperly terminating an employee’s employment for serious misconduct or terminating their employment without following proper process relevant to serious misconduct, will carry the risk of the employee commencing an unfair dismissal claim or general protection claim, and being successful with that claim.
How can we help you?
If you consider that an employee has engaged in serious misconduct, we strongly recommend that you immediately contact one of our experienced Employment Lawyers to discuss the process you should follow to minimise your risks.
It is crucial that you properly investigate allegations of serious misconduct and we can assist you to understand the appropriate procedure.
Investigations can be complex and because of this, we frequently conduct investigations for our clients. This not only provides impartiality to the investigation process, but we will provide you with a detailed report containing findings and recommendations on any disciplinary action that may be necessary.
‘Serious Misconduct’ Related News
EMPLOYMENT UPDATE
Employee’s drunken urination on co-worker not linked to employment
This Employment Update examines the High Court’s recent decision to uphold an employer’s appeal against a decision where $432,000 in damages was awarded to an employee who suffered a psychological injury after a co-worker urinated on his face while he was sleeping. This decision provides much needed clarity for employers on the issue of vicarious […]
EMPLOYMENT UPDATE
Performance management in the context of unfair dismissals
This Employment Update examines three cases where performance management processes were not undertaken properly, and so resulted in the employee having a successful unfair dismissal application. When will a dismissal be unfair An unfair dismissal occurs where the employee is dismissed and: the employer did not have a valid reason for the dismissal; the employee […]
ARTICLE
Christmas Party tips & traps
Workplace Christmas functions are a great way to reward staff and encourage connectedness, both of which are key to creating a high-performing team. However, the work Christmas party can often result in HR nightmares if handled incorrectly. We have set out a guide to ensuring your end of year celebrations remain legally uneventful: Step One: […]
EMPLOYMENT UPDATE
Reinstatement for employee following guilty verdict on criminal charges overturned
This month we deal with an extremely interesting decision of the Fair Work Commission where despite best practice investigation there was a ruling against the employer. Our key message is this should not detract from an employer seeking to follow best practice in allegations of serious misconduct. Sydney Trains has been ordered to reinstate an […]